03 · Trade practice
When the container arrives wrong: how a cross-border claim runs
Most claims are not lost on the chemistry. They are lost on sampling, on the clock, or on a contract that never said what would be tested.
First, separate three kinds of problem
A container that arrives and does not perform can be three different failures, and each has a different owner:
- The goods are not what was ordered — wrong grade, wrong solids, a batch that does not match its COA. Supplier issue: the COA and the retained sample settle it.
- The goods were damaged in transit — frozen and separated, contaminated, drums corroded. Logistics and insurance: decided by temperature records and photographs, not by a laboratory.
- The goods are correct and the mix is not — the admixture is fine, the cement or sand changed. Technical issue, and the most common of the three.
Naming the category before the first email decides the next six weeks. A claim filed as a quality problem, when the drums froze at minus eight in a feeder vessel, will be answered with a COA and will end there.
The retained sample is the only evidence that travels
A batch COA is issued at loading; a retained sample is kept from the same batch under the same conditions. When a dispute starts, that sample is what gets re-tested — not the customer's drum, which has been open for a month, and not a fresh production batch, which proves nothing about the delivered one.
This is why the retention period belongs in the contract rather than in a brochure. Twelve months covers a slow sailing, a customs hold and a first pour. Six months may not.
Sampling decides the result
A sample taken from the top of a drum that has stood for two weeks is not the product. PCE separates; the solids at the top are not the solids at the bottom. Agitate the drum, take from three containers, combine, split into two sealed samples, and send one to a laboratory agreed in advance.
Whoever controls the sample controls the argument. Agree the sampling method before there is a dispute, not after.
The clock, and the contract
Most contracts set a window — 30 days from arrival is common — in which a claim can be raised. After it, the seller's obligation to investigate weakens whatever the merits. Two clauses do most of the work:
- The retained sample is the reference, and a laboratory jointly appointed is the arbiter.
- Compatibility with the buyer's materials is not a quality defect; it is handled by technical support.
The second clause is not an escape hatch. It is what keeps a genuine adaptation problem out of a claim process that cannot solve it.
What actually resolves it
Data, quickly. A supplier that returns measured values for the retained sample within five working days, and says plainly whether the batch is in specification, ends most disputes at that point. One that answers with adjectives extends them. If the batch is out of specification, the remedy is replacement or credit — and the freight is a smaller number than the argument.
Send us your numbers
Cement type, sand MB value, haul time and temperature. The reply carries a dosage and a blend ratio, not a referral to a local agent.